Ackman's Plan for Bond Insurers Is the Best So Far

Voltron says: MBIA short seller Bill Ackman's plan for restructuring MBIA is in the best interests of the policy holders. It's apparent from MBIA's icy response that they did not even read the proposal. It is also apparent that the news media did not read the proposal. That's why you read cfcsux!

From seeking alpha.com:

Pershing Square's Bill Ackman presented his plan(.pdf) for the bond insurers MBIA (MBI) and Ambac (ABK) yesterday. Unlike the Buffett that would essentially leave the SFV (structured financial vehicle) portion of the company's to shrivel away, Ackman's plan calls the company's bluff.

Rather than have the proceeds from the Municipal portfolio flow to the holding company, Ackman is saying "let them support the losses at the SFV portfolio". Assuming the losses in SFV are as small as management says they are, this ought to work. Now, the plan falls apart if the losses are as massive as Ackman claims they will be. In this case, the Muni proceeds will not cover the losses and the house of cards come tumbling down. This is what Ackman is banking on.

Either way he wins, because if the Muni portfolio is providing liquidity to the SFV side, there are no dividends to flow up to the holding companies. Without the dividends, there is no income or revenue for the insurers. Would you buy shares in a holding company with no revenues? Me neither....